Martha’s Vineyard is one of the most beloved island destinations on the Eastern Seaboard — a place where weathered shingles meet white picket fences, where farm stands line country roads, and where the Atlantic Ocean frames nearly every view. With roughly 4 million visitors arriving each year and 124 miles of stunning coastline to explore, finding the right place to stay is one of the most important decisions you’ll make when planning your trip.
That’s where the Martha’s Vineyard Lodging Association comes in. This curated collective of independently owned and operated properties represents the very best in island hospitality. Every member property listed at marthasvineyardlodging.org has been chosen for its commitment to quality, character, and the kind of genuine, personalized service that chain hotels simply cannot replicate.
Edgartown: Elegance, History, and Harbor Views
Edgartown is the island’s most storied town, renowned for its elegant captain’s homes, the historic Old Whaling Church, world-class art galleries, and upscale dining. The Lodging Association counts thirteen exceptional Edgartown properties among its members:
- Harbor View Hotel — luxurious accommodations with elegant décor and prime harbor proximity
- The Edgar Hotel — island elegance and refined service in a historic downtown setting
- Ashley Inn — ten-bedroom Victorian inn with intimate atmosphere
- The Charlotte Inn — Edwardian elegance with tranquil gardens and gracious hospitality
- The Harborside Inn — 90-room waterfront lodging steps from Main Street with on-site dining
- The Edgartown Inn — boutique inn with personalized hospitality and waterfront proximity
- Hob Knob Boutique Hotel — 17-room award-winning boutique hotel near shopping and dining
- The Richard — refined service and classic New England style
- The Christopher — historic charm with contemporary comforts and a cozy fireplace lounge
- The Sydney — sophisticated décor and upscale amenities with easy downtown access
- Winnetu Oceanside Resort — family-owned resort near South Beach with direct beach access and spacious suites
- Edgartown Commons — vacation apartments with kitchens
- The Franklin — Short stroll from downtown Edgartown and open year round
Oak Bluffs: Victorian Charm and Vibrant Energy
Oak Bluffs pulses with a different kind of energy — colorful, festive, and deeply rooted in the island’s unique cultural history. Home to the famous Flying Horses Carousel, Circuit Avenue’s eclectic shops, and a harbor dotted with charter sailboats, Oak Bluffs is a town that invites exploration. The Association’s five Oak Bluffs members are:
- Dockside Inn — harbor-front property with scenic views and ferry terminal proximity
- Pequot Hotel — historic hotel close to the Ocean Park
- Madison Inn — centrally located 15-room inn with modern amenities
- Tivoli Inn — beautiful Victorian inn with garden courtyard
- The Oak Bluffs Inn — centrally situated, ideal for exploring shops, restaurants, and the historic carousel
- The Morgan — Comfortable rooms directly on Kennebec Avenue
- Summercamp Hotel — vibrant renovation of the historic Wesley Hotel with family-friendly rooms
Vineyard Haven: Year-Round Gateway to the Island
Vineyard Haven is the island’s primary port of entry and its most year-round-friendly town. The five Lodging Association members here are:
- Charles and Charles MV — New England-style B&B with six boutique rooms blending historic charm and contemporary accents
- Nobnocket Boutique Inn — award-winning ultra-modern design on two acres of gardens and woodland
- Mansion House Inn & Health Club — deluxe rooms with a modern health club and wellness services
- Crocker Inn — eight freshly appointed guest rooms with a relaxed dining lounge
- Vineyard Harbor Motel — budget friendly vacation apartments on the water
How to Choose Your Perfect Property
Consider your travel style. Families with children will thrive at Winnetu Oceanside Resort or Summercamp Hotel. Couples seeking romance will find their match at The Charlotte Inn, Nobnocket Boutique Inn, or Crocker Inn.
Think about timing. July and August are the island’s peak months — book early. May through June and September offer milder crowds, more availability, and often better rates.
Prioritize location. If you’re arriving by ferry, Vineyard Haven properties are ideal. If harbor views and fine dining are your priority, Edgartown’s waterfront properties are unmatched. If you want to be in the middle of the island’s social scene, Oak Bluffs is your town.
Lean into the island’s independent spirit. Martha’s Vineyard is famously free of chain stores and chain hotels. Every property listed at marthasvineyardlodging.org is independently owned and operated, which means your stay directly supports the local community and economy.
Plan Your Stay at marthasvineyardlodging.org
The Martha’s Vineyard Lodging Association exists to ensure that your time on the island is spent in accommodations that are worthy of the place itself. Every member property has been selected for its quality, character, and commitment to genuine hospitality.
Ready to start planning? Visit marthasvineyardlodging.org to browse all member properties, compare options by town and style, and book directly with the innkeepers and hoteliers who know this island best. Your perfect Martha’s Vineyard stay is waiting.